Tuesday 25 February 2020

With a forward-looking outreach, Trump made all the right noises


The city of Ahmedabad has been witnessing hectic renovation activity for over a month gearing up to host, “Namaste Trump” much along the lines of the “Howdy Modi” at Houston, August last year. President Trump’s first visit to India, in his first term, days after he is acquitted of impeachment trial by the Senate in an election year was widely critiqued.  

In the run up to Trump’s visit, there has been an exaggerated media coverage about the amount expended for the Namaste Modi event. A letter to Mike Pompeo by four US senators, two democrats and two Republicans ahead of Trump’s visit to India seeking a reassessment of CAA and abrogation of article 370 had only heightened concerns of plausible fruitful visit. Unfazed by the collapse of a putative trade deal and unmindful of the sceptics, who prophesised the visit to be high on optics and low on substance, playing a role of gracious host, India extended a spectacular welcome to President Trump.

Hyperventilating at few discordant notes, sceptics undermined the strategic dimension of the Indo-US relationship amidst rapidly changing world order. The ludicrous postulations from the Congress party’s mouth piece, National Herald, “India is the only poor and ‘shit-hole country’ Donald Trump has ever visited” conjectured their bias and disdain towards Trump. They assiduously portrayed Trump’s visit as purely electoral campaigning exercise. While an Indian outreach in the election year can have inherent political connotations but the incredulous, unwelcoming, op-Ed reflected their vociferous hatred towards Trump and their disdain for visit which has immense strategic significance.

Accepting Indian Prime Minister’s invitation, Trump embarked on a 36-hour visit to India and landed in Ahmedabad today morning. Indian government left no stone unturned in offering a phenomenal welcome to President Trump. As expected, the visit which was high in optics, turned into a moment of celebration with India displaying its vibrant diversity in full splendour. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi received Trump at the Ahmedabad airport. After the signature bear hug and thumping handshakes, the leaders kicked off a 22km-long road show. Along the entire stretch nearly 50 stages were erected where artistes from different parts of India performed in their traditional attire.  Leaders made first stop over at the Sabarmati Ashram, where Modi explained the crucial role played by Mahatma Gandhi in India’s Freedom Struggle. Overwhelmed by the warm reception, a delighted Trump left a message in the visitor’s book- “To my great friend Prime Minister Modi- Thank you for this wonderful visit”.

Visibly delighted by a sea of humanity at the Motera Stadium, Trump who has yearning for the crowds greeted them with, “Namaste” and thanked them for a “spectacular welcome” and “remarkable hospitality”. Referring to Modi as an “exceptional leader, a great champion of Indiaand tremendously successful leader”. Trump hailed Modi’s landslide electoral victory and extolled him “living proof of hard work and devotion”. Trumps’ endorsement of Modi’s attributes at a time when USCIRF has been seeking sanctions against India is indeed, an aspect to reckon with.

Needless to say, personal chemistry between both the leaders has been a driving force for the substantial progress in Indo-US strategic cooperation under Trump’s administration. Like Modi, Trump is master of the job and is known to pass orders. Mutual admiration of the leaders in the long term will this bode well for Indo-US relationship as well.

While it can be argued that India played well to Trump’s fascination for crowds to win his appreciation, on the contrary, Trump through his earnest enumeration of India’s tale of astounding progress won the hearts of Indians.  Unlike his typical oratory which is replete of jarred notes, glitches and goof-ups, Trump stumped the crowds by quoting relevant numbers. His appreciation of India’s fervent attempts to scale the economic trajectory seemed genuine. He reminded that in the past seven decades, India has become an economic giant and by the turn of the millennium, Indian economy increased six times. Trump’s rather pragmatic account of India’s economic landscape at a time, it is referred to as a “flagging economy” should bring cheer to investors who are rather despondent.

The unmissable euphemism associated with Indo-US engagement connotating as coming together of “the largest and the oldest democracies” is not lost on Trump.  Hailing India as “democratic, peaceful, break-free and tolerant country”, Trump rendered virulent anti-India propaganda of infamously referring to elected Indian government as “fascist, Nazi regime” irrelevant. Contrasting India’s unrivalled accomplishments to the coercion, aggression and intimidation of countries (veiled dig at China) which is a bane in the free world he underscored the importance of free society which drives innovation and creativity. Paying ode to India as hub of genius and creativity, Trump invoked the Bollywood, block blusters- Sholay and DDLJ. Given Indians penchant for Cricket he spoke of Sachin Tendulkar and Virat Kohli. Reciprocating India’s love he mentioned about India’s festivals- Diwali, Holi, tallest statue of Sardar Vallabhai Patel and even Swami Vivekananda. Trump eloquently touched aspects of shared values, common interests, held ode to the splendour of India’s cultural heritage.

Pledging a “good and great trade deal”, Trump effortlessly segued into the economic and strategic aspects of the Indo-US ties. Unlike major World leaders who are reluctant to call a “spade a spade”, Trump spoke of threat from “radical Islamic terror” and “militants operating from inside Pakistani borders” but resisted from the temptation to offer to mediate Kashmir issue. With a deal with Afghan Taliban around the corner, Trump stopped short of going ballistic on Pakistan but offered cooperation on counter terror cooperation to extricate terror. Hinting at the main agenda of bilateral talks, Trump asserted, “together we will defend our sovereignty, security and protect a Free and Open Indo-Pacific for our children and many generations to come”. Claiming the credit for the decimation of the ISIS caliphate and killing of its founder and Ieader, Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi, affirmed the might of American military forces. By conceding that every country has the historic right to deny permission and admission to elements that threaten the security and peace of the country, Trump has refused to interfere in India’s internal issues (here CAA). He added, “every nation has right to secure and controlled borders”. America’s willingness to sell sophisticated defence technologies including armed and unarmed drones, air defence missile systems and the largest trilateral exercises- “TigerTriumph” demonstrate that Indo-US relations are growing from strength to strength.

Indo-US trade has doubled in the last ten years and holds tremendous potential for growth. America is India’s largest trade market. A booming American economy will be in the best interest of India. Negotiations are in process for sealing a trade deal, USTR (US Trade Representative) issued executive order classifying India as a “developed nation” making India ineligible for GSP (Generalised System of Preferences). Certain sectors will be hard hit. No doubt, a trade deal will be a fantastic idea. But Trump has postponed it to November after his re-election.

Trump’s cultural overtures, and attempts to consolidate people to people connect heaping praise on the 4 million Indian Diaspora,-“ they are the titans of business, the biggest, the best pioneers of science, master of art, and innovation of technology like few people have been able to see no matter where you go anywhere in the universe” have certainly made a mark on Indian masses. He touched all the right cords and made every attempt to appreciate the essence of India and even acknowledged it spiritual pre-eminence.

Strategically Trump’s visit is shot in arm for India. It is a message to neighbours Pakistan-which seeks hyphenation and China for raking up discordant notes in the Indo-US relations. Despite a major revamp in the World order, America is a superpower and continues to occupy a pivotal position on global platform. Washington’s renewed trust in India will bode well for strengthening strategic partnership with like-minded countries like Japan, Australia, France and New Zealand. With every passing year, India has been expanding the matrix of cooperation. By acknowledging India’s civilisational values, vibrancy of diversity, Trump had indeed, strengthened the bonds of friendship. By reposing trust, Trump has cemented the partnership which is pivoted on the strength of shared values, ideas and principles.

Above all, by not getting drawn by the cacophony of the rancorous propaganda of domestic opposition which is seeking active advocates in foreign lands, Trump has earned the respect of India which is attempting to correct historical wrongs that have been an affront on the social, political, economic and strategic aspirations of the country.


@ Copyrights reserved.

No comments: