Wednesday 18 July 2018

Sham elections and fake democracy of Pakistan


With little less than a fortnight to Pakistan’s general elections, high political drama unfolds with the arrest of three-time Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and his daughter Maryam Nawaz in Avenfield property case. Earlier, National Accountability Bureau (NAB) convicting both on corruption charges pronounced a verdict of £8 million fine and 10 years jail term for Sharif and £2.5 million fine, 7 years imprisonment and as punishment for Maryam Sharif. Pakistan observers described this development nothing less than a “judicial coup”. Sharif’s imprisonment without proper trial confirmed Pakistan’s sanctimonious reputation of fictitious democracy. Since independence in 1947, not even a single prime minister has completed a full term. Nearly all of them are either assassinated, imprisoned, coerced or ousted from power in military coups. Indeed, the entire façade of a democratic civil administration is just a gloss since the real power lies with military establishment. Strong institutional framework, characteristic of every democratic country is in tatters in Pakistan.

It is a no secret that authoritarianism of military subdues every other institution in Pakistan coming in its path. Corruption has been a menacing issue in Pakistan. Interestingly military-intelligence ecosystem of the country which is making piquant argument of culling corrupt politicians should be subjected to such scrutiny for being endemically corrupt. Besides, the two edicts which are now cited as reasons for disqualification of Sharif-sadiq and ameen meaning honesty and righteousness are added to the constitution in 1980 under the third schedule by despotic Mohammed Zia-ul-Haq. Determined to steer Pakistan towards Islamization, Haq argued that legislators should conform to these basic tenets. Ever since not a single politician was ever punished for corruption.

In 2016 facing international backlash for failing to rein in on the activities of terror modules operating from Pakistani territory, Sharif pulls up Pakistan military. This unprecedented warning and civil administration’s tough posturing has irked military but struck cord with aspirations of common man. Sharif’s reputation a tough politician began to find ground. Even his eventual re-election in 2018 seemed certain. At this juncture, military who scoffed Sharif, supported Imran Khan’s, prime minister aspirant and founder of Pakistan Tehreek Insaf (PTI) demand for probe into Panama Papers revelations. Soon a JIT (Joint Investigation Team) was constituted with ISI and intelligence officers in November 2016. Pakistan military thus diligently employed political rivalry and ambitions of Khan to engineer ouster of Sharif meticulously.  In July 2017, Supreme Court, disqualified Prime Minister Sharif on corruption allegations for concealing his assets, bringing about his unceremonious exit one year ahead of his full term. With this the three-time Prime Minister failed to complete not even a single term completely.

Sharif, born into the family of Kashmiri industrialists in 1949, devastated by the nationalisation of their family steel business joined Pakistan Muslim League (PML) party in 1976. Military who was looking for an urban politician found Sharif promising and groomed him. Soon Sharif developed good connections with Pakistan’s top tier army officials and steadily rose in political circles. He was inducted as finance minister in federal cabinet in 1981 and in 1985 he became chief minister of Punjab and formed PML-N (Nawaz). PML (N), a conservative, capitalist right wing party soon dumped nationalisation policy of Haq. Under the tenure of Sharif, Punjab registered substantial growth which catapulted his reputation as a committed leader. With the support of military establishment, he became Prime Minister in 1990 and in 1993 he was removed by President. He was re-elected in 1997 but was overthrown in a military coup by General Pervez Musharraf. Convicted of corruption charges in 2000, he exiled to Saudi Arabia and following Presidential pardon after ouster of Pervez Musharraf he returned to Pakistan but lost in the 2008 elections. In 2013, Sharif was elected as Prime Minister for third time.

Just before elections, in April, inflicting a huge blow to Sharif’s political career, Supreme Court pronounced a life time ban from political office. In what can be termed as the unparalleled witch-hunt, Supreme Court, working in tandem with Pakistan military convicted Sharif and his political heir Maryam in absentia on July 6th.

Sharif’s conviction has become matter of intense debate since military didn’t raise any objections to any of his corrupt practices in the initial days of his political career. Military which had busy in handling other political rivals ignored Sharif’s pursuit towards wealth acquisition. Husain Haqqani, former Pakistani Ambassador precisely points out to this aspect, “One need not be convinced of Sharif’s innocence to observe that he was victim of less than transparent legal proceedings. His downfall started when military got upset with an article in Dawn suggesting that civilian government wanted to act against jihadis but the military did not”. In 1990’s military’s crackdown on Benazir Bhutto’s Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) on corruption charges significantly enhanced electoral prospects of PML (N). By parting ways with military Sharif has become victim of Pakistan’s perverse judicial system while Imran Khan is reaping political benefits of military’s targeted campaign against his rival. Khan who is now cynosure of deep state is currently leading the electoral race of 2018.

More than two decades into active politics, Imran Khan of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, (PTI) having learned tricks of trade is now inching closer to his dream of becoming Prime Minister. According to reports, PTI is likely to emerge as the single largest party. The military in cahoots with judiciary having literally stone-walled the electoral prospects of Nawaz Sharif’s PML (N) has eased Imran’s journey to the coveted post. Khan who has imbued all the desirable attributes of playing perfect fiddle to military is now poised to win the elections. While political parties like PPP is denied permission to hold rallies Khan never encountered such difficulties. Even media was ordained to allot more air time to Khan and asked to black out any disparaging content against Khan. Rehman Khan, second wife of Khan was issued a legal notice to stop publishing her book alleging Khan of fathering five illegitimate kids. Accordingly, even Khan’s previous stint as a flamboyant play-boy image is also made up to suit the conservative approach. To buttress, Khan’s portrayal as incorruptible, corruption charges against him are quashed by Supreme Court. Khan entered the elections with a single point agenda of fighting corruption and accountability.  Reuters claims that 21 candidates PML(N) lawmakers have switched sides and joined PTI following threats of corruption charges against them by intelligence agents. While Khan denies having any understanding with military generals the collusion seems to be more than significant.

Poll surveys predict an overwhelming win for Khan in 2018 elections. Chasing his dream, Khan forged ties with fundamentalist Islamic groups. He now supports blasphemy, tows a strong Anti-Americanism, a prerequisite for such alliances. He strongly denounces liberals as scum, has little respect for democratic values and clings to retrograde views. His anti-India narrative and an aggressive Kashmir policy has earned him friends from deep state. In short, he has aligned with every possible group in Pakistan with significant clout for his political ascension. At a time, when Pakistan ailing economy is reeling under the burden of spiralling trade deficit and debts, neither military nor the people seem to be least bothered about attributes of plausible prime minister candidate. Ironically Pakistan Army is not interested in a realistic and independent leader but aspires to bequeath power to a pliable and amenable person. Though Pakistan proclaims itself as a democratic country, upcoming elections are everything other than being free and fair. Clearly, these elections will neither revive Pakistan’s stuttering economy nor bring respite from reign of terror. While military made grand efforts for a smooth sail of Khan in elections, Sharif’s return to Pakistan to court arrest has tilted the scales in favour of the later.

Though Pakistan is turning into a jihadi den, military has turned blind eye towards it and indeed, it is now making every effort to mainstream cultivated strategic assets, Jihadi militant outfits. Over 150 candidates from extremist groups, some of who are included in fourth schedule for terrorism are now allowed to contest. Hafiz Talha Saeed, son and Hafiz Khaleed Wahleed son-in-law of JuD (Jammat ud Dawa) head Hafiz Saeed, who masterminded 26/11 and carries $10million bounty for terror activities are now contesting elections. JuD earlier formed a political party, Mili Muslim League (MML) to fight elections. But election commission (EC) refused to recognise this party. Saeed’s motely group of 265 terrorists are now in election fray under the little known political party, Allahu Akbar Tehreek (AAT) registered with EC.

In the run up to election three lethal bomb rocked secular parties’ election campaigns at Bannu, Mastung and Peshawar raising concerns of burgeoning radical terrorism and ineptness of Pakistan’s military and intelligence. SC issued fresh summons for illegally channelling funds through benami accounts were issued to PPP Co-Chairman Asif Zardari and his sister Faryal Talpur and FIA took Zardari’s aide Hussain Lawai, a banker. Ironically, the military instead of addressing the security lapses worked overnight to put Sharif behind bars.

Unlike in 2000, when Sharif sought Presidential pardon and exiled to Saudi Arabia, he has decided to put up a stiff fight. Crushing the raising support for Sharif, Punjab police issued orders to arrest, PML (N) leader, former federal railway minister Saad Rafique, seven PML(N) leaders are kept under house arrest. Over 400 party workers are detained to thwart any attempts to welcome Sharif. Sharif who has returned to Lahore after posting poignant pictures faring good bye to his ailing wife Kulsoom Nawaz to court arrest is currently riding high on sympathy wave. While army might have accomplished the task of crushing Sharif by lodging him and his heir apparent Maryam Nawaz. In the meanwhile, PML (N) has intensified twitter campaign on illegal detention of party workers and unprecedented restraints on freedom of press. Upright journalists are assaulted or even kidnapped. Sharif’s reputation seems to have surged with his masterstroke of courting arrest. Urban populace is now increasingly considerate about Sharif. The party which seems to have lost out in the election race has picked up momentum is now heavily banking on the loyalties of Punjabi electorate. Sharif’s has sought legal recourse and appealed for bail which is turned down by Supreme Court. SC argued that Sharifs should be held in jail until the completion of elections. Army as the most-powerful institute is highly revered in Pakistan, but crackdown of civil liberties with iron hand might eventually open a new dynamic. High profile drama days before election has effectively set stage for an election thriller.

@ Copyrights reserved.

No comments: